Friday, November 20, 2026

JD Vance Needs to Unite MAGA, Not Divide It


person 1: But I wanted to turn then to [Vice President] JD Vance‘s interview with Laura Ingraham, which was actually very good. He talked a lot about the accomplishments made—

person 2: He did—

person 1: He does say at one point about the Iran war that there are some hawks that want a forever war, but that’s not what he wanted. And I was wondering why that seemed a little bit hostile against the administration, that he’s separating himself.

person 2: I don’t understand that comment because the midterms themselves were not quite as bad as the Obama wipeout. They were more like the Clinton or Reagan wipeouts.

But they were worse in a waybecause places that have not been Democratic ever, or haven’t been since the ’60s and ’70s, and I’m talking about Georgia, Kansas, Indiana, Iowa, Ohio, went blue. So it was serious.

And it seems in that acrimony, this cannibalism that’s going on, everybody’s fighting. It was the bad candidates. No, no, no, it was a war. No, it was gas. No, no, no, it was corruption. No, it was turnout. No, it was apostates.

You would think that the vice president would want to unify these factions.

So, what I might have said is, we had a disagreement over the war, and that’s natural among like-minded friends. Nobody wants a forever war. Nobody wants an endless war. Donald Trump campaigned on, this is not a forever war. And there were two camps. One felt that after 38 days, the nuclear threat was neutered, and the industrial-military threat was diminished, and that we should now negotiate our way out.

The other group felt that you could not trust the Iranians to negotiate in good faith, and they wanted another two or three weeks. We don’t know what we’re going to do. Well, I shouldn’t say that. Let me restate that.

So, what we’re going to do is make sure they do not have nuclear material. And we’re on the verge of a dramatic decline in the industrial output, the military output of the Iranian theocratic regime.

So, one way or the other, they’re not going to have a bomb, and they’re not going to pose a threat. But there is differences about how to achieve that common goal.

If he had just said that. But he really says that if you’re one of the people listening, and you supported the effort to denuclearize Iran, and you felt that after five weeks, and hearing what we heard, and knowing what we know about the diminishment of their military-industrial complex, you were kind of surprised when they stopped and they started negotiating.

You said, well, they’re just about ready to collapse. No wonder they want [negotiations]. And then it was, well, don’t worry, there’s eight months in the midterms. Don’t worry, there’s seven months. Don’t worry, there’s six months. Don’t worry, we’re going to have a memorandum.

And then JD inserted himself, and he was the point man on the idea of negotiations. But then he fell back as the people who saw that the negotiations had utterly failed, they fell back to a safety position, which was, we were always against it. We’re trying to bail you out of your war. It’s not our war. It’s your forever war.

Well, the other side says, no, 40 days or 50 days to get Iran denuclearized would have been worth it. And we were almost there, but we listened to you people.

So, there’s this disagreement, and he could have just framed both sides and said, we’re in the same party, and we don’t want to fight about it. But instead they get this—

And all the people around him, you know, you go into social media. I don’t like doing it, but to prep for this, I see what people are saying. You look at what [Steve] Bannon and Candace Owens and Tucker [Carlson] and this Brandon Weichert and all these people are saying. They use these terms so loosely. Forever war, boomers, forever war, neocons.

And as I said before, I would like somebody in the MAGA movement to say, I am a neocon. I haven’t heard one person say that, because they do not believe in nation-building. They do not believe in ground troops. They do not believe in occupation. And they believe the military may say you need ground troops. Military says you’ve got to get in there and stabilize it. But the MAGA people said, we did that, been there, did that in Afghanistan and Iraq, and we’re not going to do it again. That’s Jacksonianism.

But I don’t know anybody that fits the straw man image that they are neocons. I do know there’s neocons, and they are people who hate the MAGA movement. And the moderate ones are at The Dispatch, and I think most of them are still Republicans. And they think they’re going to reemerge after Trump is gone. And the MAGA movement, I don’t think the MAGA movement’s going to go anywhere. But anyway, they still credibly see themselves as center-right. The Bulwark is not. They’re back where neocons came from.

Remember, neo means new conservative. And it’s unfortunately been a synonym for Jewish people. In other words, when you hear a person say, oh, the neocons got us into the war, and Israel. And that’s because they feel that the original neocon movement of the 1970s that abandoned Jimmy Carter, the Democrats and leftists, and joined Ronald Reagan after the Iranian hostage situation and the rise of an aggressive Soviet Russia.

They said we’re throwing our lot, hold our nose, and go with Reagan. They did not agree with Reagan on border enforcement. They did not agree with him on abortion, but on foreign policy, they did. That was the neocons. And were they all Jews? No. There were prominent Jews: Irving Kristol, Norman Podhoretz, of course, Paul Wolfowitz.

But there were also people like James Q. Wilson and Bill Bennett and Francis Fukuyama and Jeane Kirkpatrick. Most prominent of all, John Bolton.

It wasn’t just a Jewish group. And more importantly, they formed something called the Project for the New American Century, which basically said we’re going to remake things by military force. And that kinda died after Afghanistan and Iraq.

But my point is, there are no neocons. There’s nobody who believes in neoconservative foreign policy in the MAGA movement, and the people who are accusing them of that are saying that the thirty-eight-day war that you supported, and we, our group, stopped through endless negotiations, proved you’re a neocon. And I don’t think it’s wise to do that, because—

person 1: No—

person 2: JD’s looking at the polls that are people—There’s two types of polls. After seven or eight months that we didn’t win and were indecisive, there’s an unpopularity in the Republican Party. Probably 60% is against the war, but at the beginning of the war, 85% supported getting rid of their nuclear weapons.

Which should remind him maybe that had we just kept going and did that and won. People want to win. They want a winner. What they’re tired of: Vietnam and Korea and Afghanistan and Iraq.

Their idea is like, if I could represent it, is “Just win, baby.” Al Davis, Oakland Raiders. If you go start a war, as Napoleon said, if you’re gonna take Vienna, my marshals, take it. If you’re gonna go into that miasma of the Middle East and take on that brutal, theocratic, murderous regime, then you better finish the job. Do not wound that animal and turn it loose in the Middle East. So that’s a Jacksonian. It’s not a neoconservative position.

person 1: Yeah. Yeah.

person 2: And I think JD was just kind of reacting proactively or preemptively to criticism of him. There’s a lot of people that say that he was the architect of the memorandum of understanding. It didn’t work very well.

I like JD. But I think somebody, I think people need to advise him that when he uses the word boomers or neocons or endless wars or forever wars, that doesn’t go down well with the whole spectrum of the MAGA movement. Because it’s now become loaded, because people who support JD more so than, say, other people in the MAGA movement, and I’m talking mostly about the Tucker Carlson that’s their vocabulary. That is their vocabulary.

person 1: I saw a poll that Rubio has 40% support and JD has, like, 10%. Was there a poll out there like that?

person 2: Yes, there was. Forty-three percent.

person 1: Forty-three percent. So JD has really—

person 2: One poll has [Florida Gov. Ron] DeSantis higher than JD.

person 1: Even DeSantis higher than JD. That’s a problem for JD anyways.

person 2: What I don’t understand is this. JD performed brilliantly in the campaign. And he tore apart all of these left-wing charlatans on the news shows. And he took Trump’s MAGA message, and he stayed on point. So, you had Trump as sort of a master of ceremonies, “Celebrity Apprentice”-type rallies, and then he would go on TV and complement them by filling in the blanks. ‘Cause they’d say, well, Trump gave it, and he said this. Yes, here’s what he meant. And he went da, da, da, da, da, da, and it was very good. And so, he was the heir-to-be.

But it wasn’t just that Tucker disagreed. Tucker said things about the president that no vice president can not reply to. He said that he was satanic. He was the satanic. He was the Antichrist, and he hoped he would not … He rooted against the midterms. He endorsed all sorts of candidates, and he allied himself with Marjorie Taylor Greene and Thomas Massie and that group. Okay.

That group never represented more than 10% at most. Maybe the Groypers, the young people, maybe 15%. That was not where the full weight of the MAGA dash Republican Party was. But maybe it was out of loyalty. He didn’t want to.

But what I’m getting at is, Tucker kept pushing the envelope. It was almost as if he was saying, “OK, JD, I know we helped you, and I was the guy who lobbied you for you to be vice president. Don’t be an ingrate, but I’m going to test this, your character. So I’m going to say something more outrageous each week and put you on a spot. At some point, you’re either going to have to support me and thank me for helping you get the nomination, or you can join the other people and not—you’ll be a target of me.” That was what the implied threat was.

And so the vice president, as I’ve said so many times: go to funerals, break Senate ties, and protect the president. And he should have said—this wouldn’t have happened if he had just done two things. “I like Tucker Carlson. He’s been a big supporter of mine, but I think he’s wrong here. And I think my duty as vice president is to protect the presidency, and Donald Trump in particular. He is not, Tucker, satanic. He’s doing a great job, and I hope you can come to see that.”

That’s all he had to say. And I will be critical of anybody who calls my president satanic, and I don’t think he would be in this.

And then the other thing he needed to do, if he feels that Benjamin Netanyahu exercised an undue influence, is—what’s emerging now is that Trump was really— because Trump has made up with Tucker today. Tucker and he are talking again. Tucker is telling the world that Donald Trump came to the Tucker, saw the light and came to Tucker’s position, and he’s calling him.

It’s never wise to tell people how many times the President of the United States calls you. That puts the President of the United States in a terrible position. You mean you’re calling somebody, you know, da, da, da, da, da.

And so, my point is, all he had to do is say Israel is a great ally. It’s the only democratic society in the Middle East. But at certain points, we obviously have different ideas about how to address the common threat that Israel and the United States face.

We have global responsibility that Israel doesn’t. So obviously we have to worry about Taiwan, we have to worry about Ukraine, and we have to worry about the Middle East. But because of Israel’s vulnerability, it has to worry about Iran.

And sometimes people confuse that.

I’m talking as if I’m JD right now. Sometimes people confuse that, and they think that because we help Israel, that we are being dominated. Three hundred and forty million people are being dominated by ten million Jewish Israeli citizens, and that’s not true.

When we have parallel or identical interests, we work together, and when we don’t, we respectfully go our own ways, and we still help each other, but we don’t actually share that same mission on that same time and that same place. That’s all he has to say.

But instead, we got into forever wars and neocons and Israel, and right after the midterms, four reasons why we lost: the war, the economy, we weren’t true to MAGA ideal, and Israel. Well, all that did was just turn off, it turned off the Jewish community, it turned off people who feel the evangelical community, and it turned off a lot of Republicans, ’cause they overwhelmingly support the Jewish state.

And they feel they have to more than ever, because the Left not just opposes it, but does things that are reminiscent of the worst chapters in our history. When you have in Philadelphia a left-wing march synchronized with the anniversary of Kristallnacht, and they’re celebrating what the Nazis did basically to Jewish stores, and they’re picking out Jewish stores to protest and to demonstrate and to injure.

And when you have that, you’ve got to speak out against it. And if you don’t, and you say that Israel is one of the reasons that we lost the midterms, meaning the Jewish people in the United States that support Israel, then that feeds into what you see with these Kristallnacht celebrations.

person 1: Yeah, exactly.

The Problem With the New American Left

 

What is the Left today? What is the Democratic Party? What term do you use? It’s so strange. It’s so unfamiliar. Let’s try to do a typology of it, and let’s start with the premise that the Democratic Party we knew, some of us of our generation in the 1990s, it was very successful under Bill Clinton.

Not that it ever won 51% of the vote, but it was able to leverage the Ross Perot candidacy and gain control of the presidency and, for a few years, some of Congress as well.

And what did it stand for? Well, we can only determine that by looking at the 1992 platform at the Democratic Convention that nominated Bill Clinton, who was elected, and then his reelection platform in the ’96 Democratic Convention.

And what were they for? They were for closed borders. They were for deportations. They were for protection of American workers. They were for moderate tariffs. They were very suspicious of China. They were for adding 100,000 policemen. They were for trying violent juvenile offenders as adults.

I could go on, but my gosh, you can get the picture.

They even balanced the budget, and they succeeded in that with the help of Newt Gingrich and the Republican opposition for four years: ’98, ’99, 2000, 2001. I think it’s fair to say that that Democratic Party and what I just talked about was mostly the intellectual work of Doug Schoen and Mark Penn, to a lesser extent, James Carville.

Those people are completely gone. I mean, they’re still active, and they comment, and they’re still loyal Democrats for the most part, but they’ve been completely ignored. And that Democratic Party today, today looks like it’s a Republican Party.

They want nothing to do with that legacy. Bill Clinton is not revered, revered as a person that really got the country moving and did a lot of good things.

So, who’s left? Well, there’s still some ossified liberals. These are kind of like Clinton, but they were more liberal. I guess this is Chuck Schumer, Nancy Pelosi. These are people who were on the left wing of the Bill Clinton Democratic Party. Left wing. They were a little bit stronger. They wanted universal health care.

They were the Obama progressives. Universal health care. They wanted, you know, Cash for Clunkers. They warred on fossil fuels, but not in an extreme fashion. They kinda, sorta wanted the border open, kinda, sorta, sorta closed. They would say things, “We can’t have illegal aliens, but who’s going to do our wash or, our wash or cook our meals or pick our crops?”

They were liberal on free speech at that time. There was no trans issue. They were anti-pornography, but not to the extent they wanted to ban it. they were kind of Playboy liberals.

Those progressives are not there anymore. I guess you could say that the liberals are ossified and gone, and what replaced them, the progressives, they were kind of like, I don’t know, Elizabeth Warren.

They wanted consumer protection, and they wanted to sue corporations, and they were the Greenpeace people, and they wanted to get a lot more muscular. They were the liberals. I’m trying to perhaps make a distinction that doesn’t really exist between ossified liberals and calcified progressives. But the progressives were a little bit to the left, and Elizabeth Warren, I guess, versus what? Chuck Schumer. But they were still in the same ballpark. And once in a while, they would work with the Republicans, not like Bill Clinton. But they were big-spending liberals, and they were more socially active on matters of diversity and affirmative action and feminism and gay rights.

They’re pretty much ossified now, too. Chuck Schumer is under enormous attack. Nancy Pelosi is an octogenarian on her way out.

And we now have three different groups that are starting to take over the Democratic Party. One is the DEI people. These are the so-called diversity, equity, and inclusion.

They identify mostly, not necessarily, as Indian Americans or Arab Americans or black Americans or Hispanic Americans or Native Americans, but people who are not white. Not white, the victimized class.

And this is not the generation of Charles Rangel or Jim Clyburn, the people who came out of the civil rights movement and were for the melting pot and integration and assimilation and equality of opportunity originally.

The new DEI movement wants equality of result. They want reparations. They feel—they talk nonstop about white supremacy, white privilege, white rage. They want compensatory or reparatory government to start to not ignore race. Their idea is that race is essential, not incidental to who we are. It’s our primary way of identifying.

So, these people, and the “squad” is a good example. The squad is a good example. Ilhan Omar, [Alexander Ocasio-Cortez], etc. These people now have joined with the other two elements of the new Democratic Party to be the Democratic Party. They were kind of a minority before the DEI people. The liberals and progressives ran the party.

Now the liberals and progressives are on the run. The younger DEI members are ascendant, and they have joined with two groups. The first is the Islamists. The population of people from the Middle East has grown to about 5 million people. But more importantly, they have concentrated on particular areas, Dearborn, Michigan, for example.

And they have been the beneficiaries of multibillion dollars. Fifty, 100 billion dollars have gone to universities in the last 20 years. So, when I was a graduate student in the 1970s, the Middle East departments were two or three people, and one was a Jewish historian and one was an Arab historian. Not now.

Due to gifts from Saudi Arabia, Kuwait, Qatar, the Gulf States, they have massive endowments. They have faculties of 10, 20 people. They offer all sorts of degrees, and they are the natural nexus for a huge number. 50, 60,000 students are coming in the United States from the Middle East.

Now, some of you are going to say, “Why would they want to come to America?

They’re so chauvinistic about the Arab world or the Islamic world, and they’re so critical of America because as soon as they come here, they’re overwhelmingly left-wing.

Why would they leave a place and say, “I cannot stand it here in Gaza. I cannot stand it here in the West Bank. I cannot stand it because I have no freedom. I have no economic prosperity. I have no security,” then come over to the place where all their wishes are granted, and they want to change it?

And if they were successful, they would end up changing it in a religious and constitutional or anti-constitutional model to resemble what they fled from. And who are they?

They’re the podcaster Hasan Piker. They’re Ilhan Omar. They’re Mr. Abdul El-Sayed, the new Democratic senator from [Michigan]. They’re [Rep.-elect Adam] Hamawy. He was the one that couldn’t distinguish whether, Israel or Iran was better. They were equivalent, but actually in the way he formulated, he favors Iran, as most of the Islamists do over Israel.

They’re the Zohran Mamdanis, who say he’s going to go after white, richer neighborhoods. So, this is a new group. Now, you think that they wouldn’t have a home in the Democratic Party for a variety of reasons. The Islamists have had traditional, friction with the black community, and we’re seeing a little bit of that in Detroit today, where there were some defections of black Democrats because of the El-Sayed candidacy.

But mostly, the Islamists say, “We are victims like you are of white settler colonialism, and therefore we have more in common.” They have a very shaky but still viable coalition between DEI and Islamists.

There’s the final, tessera in this Democratic new mosaic, and that’s the socialists. Now, the Democratic Socialists of America has always been an obscure, irrelevant group.

It’s 85% white. It’s mostly concentrated in Boulder, Colorado, or Brooklyn or Manhattan or Washington, D.C. or San Francisco or Austin or Portland or Seattle. Liberal enclaves of mostly white, college-educated people with high aspirations but are downwardly mobile. Their degrees in political science, in dash studies courses, in sociology, in psychology, in environmental, do not render them the type of income, prestige, and influence that they feel they deserve in these highly expensive urban enclaves.

They rub shoulders with professional lawyers, doctors, finance, Wall Street people, and they say, “He has all this money. She’s a CEO. I can’t buy a apartment. I can’t buy a home.” And they’re very bitter, and they blame their own personal unhappiness on the system. They don’t have the money of their parents.

They have student loans. They went to graduate school in many cases, and yet they’re downwardly mobile. So, now they want to destroy capitalism, universal health care for everybody. They want to raise taxes. They want to raise inheritance. They want to tax net worth, not just your income. And they have now joined with the Islamists.

Now, some of you are going to say, “This can’t happen.” The DEI Islamist socialist coalition doesn’t make any sense because socialists are either agnostic or atheist. Islamists are hyper-religious. Socialists say that they’re pan-global, that they feel that, like the old Soviet Union, that they have affinities with anybody, who is a communist or socialist.

The Islamists are ethnocentric and religious-centric. Socialists feel that the gay lifestyle is just an alternate lifestyle, the trans lifestyle. Not Islamists. Those are against the Quran. What do they have in common? What are the ossified liberals, the challenged progressives, the DEI people, the Islamists, the socialists, what holds them together now?

Two things. They despise Donald Trump to such a degree that their hatred of him and their desire to destroy him and the MAGA movement for now overcomes their individual fault lines.

And two, they despise the Jewish state of Israel and its supporters, both Jews and non-Jews. It has become a signature issue in the Democratic Party, a unifying issue.

As far as all of the other issues, they’re pretty much left-wing and in agreement on the border, on crime, on energy. But what really galvanizes these very diverse groups is, let’s put aside our differences because we agree on the two motivating issues. We despise Israel and its supporters, and we hate Donald Trump and want to see him out and the MAGA movement erased.

That’s the new Democratic Party.

The Problem With the New American Right

 

We live in very confusing times. Let’s start with the Right or the Republicans or the conservatives. Who is what and what is who?

Well, let’s break down the people who now sort of identify as conservative, as right. There was originally “Never Trumpers.”

That was one part of the party. These were the people who had believed in free and unfettered trade, basically open borders, abortion on demand. They really didn’t want to get into cultural issues. They did believe in libertarian, free-market economy and, you could say, strong defense. Not now. The Never Trumpers are really in two branches.

The most extreme are what I would call the apostate Never Trumpers. These are people who hated MAGA to such a degree, and Donald Trump in particular, that they have gone full bore left-wing in response.

So, you have people like George Will now who endorse Democratic candidates. You have people in The Bulwark, especially Bill Kristol and his associates, who are endorsing Zohran Mamdani and Abdul El-Sayed.

So, they’re no longer in the Right. They are not just Democrats. They’re hard-left Democrats, and they are still consumed with Trump derangement syndrome.

But there’s another group of apostates, left Never Trumpers, and these are people who didn’t like Donald Trump. They didn’t like the MAGA movement, but they considered them better than the alternative, sort of.

And they go between 51% supporting Trump and 49%. They’re usually very critical of Donald Trump, and they play down his successes and exaggerate his deficiency because they feel he deviated from the George Bush, John McCain, Bob Dole, Mitt Romney gold standard of Republicanism.

And who are they? They’re people in The Wall Street Journal, people in the National Review Online, the orthodox Republican Party, the establishment Republican Party.

Notice that there’s not very many people in the establishment Republican Party in the so-called Republican Congress. That may change because of the MAGA defeats in the midterms.

But so far, it’s been remarkable that the McCain, Romney, Bob Dole, Bush wing and its advocacy of libertarian laissez-faire economics, open borders, abortion, and then they agree with Donald Trump on a number of other issues, have not been able to take the reins back and control the party as they did.

One of the reasons is that people remember that they had, not really won 51% of the vote since 1988. And candidates like George H.W. Bush and George W. Bush, who won in 2004 against John Kerry, but earlier, Bob Dole that tried to run against Bill Clinton.

And, of course, John McCain and Mitt Romney turned off about 20 million would-be Republican voters who did not come out to vote for them.

And those were won back into the fold by the MAGA people. Now, the MAGA, for now, is mainstream, but it is divided really in two.

I shouldn’t say in two. It’s disproportionately divided. I would say about 80% of them are doctrinaire Trump supporters. In foreign policy, that means they’re Jacksonians. Domestic policy, they’re for strict secure borders, ending the Green New Deal subsidies, fossil fuel development, taking an active stance, culturally, against NPR, PBS, the media, the universities, DEI, etc.

But they have a divide on foreign policy. And I would call these people the new neo-isolationists. They disagree with the Jacksonians, the regular MAGA people in two key areas. No. 1, they are neo-isolationists. They don’t want to be involved at all overseas, even when that does not involve ground troops.

They were critical of the Trump elimination of terrorist Gen. Qasem Soleimani in the first term and Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi. They were critical of the Nicolas Maduro successful extradition. They were critical of the brief bombing in 2025 of the nuclear … They want nothing to do. They are isolationists.

They define “America First” not as taking care of American security, even if it means warding off potential or current enemies.

It’s just a Fortress America, attack.

And the second big issue that separates the MAGA movement is that the neo-isolationists, the new isolationists want us not just to cut off aid to Israel. Donald Trump is apparently going to do that in 2027. They want to radically change our relationship with Israel.

They feel that in the recent Oct. 7, 2023, massacre and what followed in Gaza was good evidence that we are on the wrong side of that conflict. So they, in this very strange way, support the Gazans and the Palestinians over Israel.

And the MAGA people are bewildered by this isolationist wing because after all, Israel is the only consensual free society and Western society in the Middle East surrounded by 500 million people of the Islamic faith that live in autocratic societies and are pledged in the most part to destroy Israel.

But that’s the divide. There’s two other groups in the Republican Party now, and they are even to the right of the MAGA isolationists, and that is I’d call the Carlsonites. Those are followers of Tucker Carlson.

They believe not just in the isolationist view, the J.D. Vance view of foreign policy and the suspicion of Israel, but they feel that the United States is on completely the wrong track and that they feel that we have downplayed the dangers of legal immigration, legal immigration.

That because we’re not assimilating people, in the first or second immigrant generation, that we should stop most all immigration.

A lot of people have moderate, moderated views of that, but they have a racial component to it. They believe, the Tucker Carlson people, that the country was founded by 94% people from Europe, so-called whites, and therefore we must retain that strong Christian white, indigenous identity is what they call it. They have enemies on the Right, and those are a much more ascendant group, the so-called Groypers.

These are Nick Fuentes’ people. And they agree with the Carlsonites in a lot of different ways. They go back in history and say the Jews were the problem a lot of in history. They say that World War II, we should have not joined World War II on the side of Britain, much less Russia. They rewrite that.

They have skepticism of the Holocaust. They believe Jews … they’re much more explicit than Tucker Carlson’s group about the pernicious, supposed pernicious, nature of, Jewishness in the United States. They believe that you have to be actively antisemitic and actively anti-immigrant and actively pro-white and actively, take on the Republican Party and the MAGA movement.

It’s kind of ironic that the most vehement enemies now of MAGA are not necessarily doctrinaire Democrats or people in the democratic socialist, even Islamist movement. It’s the Carlsonites and the Groypers especially who have delighted in the midterm defeat of the MAGA movement, as if they’re saying to us:

“We agree with you on the border. We agree with you on deportations. We agree with you on the dangers of DEI. We agree with you on lowering the crime rate, and we agree with you to make America strong defensively. But because of your relationship with Israel and the Iran war, we hope you lose everything and that agenda is wiped out and the Democrats come in and the whole party blows up. And among the ashes, the Groyper Carlson Phoenix will arise, and a new type of conservatism will emerge.”

I think that’s delusional, but we’ll find out.

Everyone’s a Neocon—Except the Actual Neocons

 

We’re hearing a lot of criticism, both from the Left and the Right, the extreme right, about neocons, neocons, neocons.

And the criticism is that a group of people called neocons have hijacked the Trump MAGA foreign policy, usually doing the service of Israel, and they’re unduly influenced by a Jewish lobby, and they don’t represent the real interests of the United States.

Neoconservative, the word that they’re abbreviating, just means new conservative. Where did it come from? It came from the 1970s and ’80s, when a group of very distinguished liberals, Jewish and non-Jewish, decided that they’d had it with Jimmy Carter. He did not react in a muscular fashion to the Iranian hostage-taking of ’79 and ’80, and he wasn’t standing up to the Soviet Union.

They wanted to adopt the Reagan doctrine of we win, they lose. Who were they? Well, there were some Jewish Americans, Irving Kristol, Norman Podhoretz, but there were also non-Jewish people, James Q. Wilson, Bill Bennett, especially Jeane Kirkpatrick. And they all said that from now on, they were going to support the foreign policy of Republicans.

They disagreed with traditional Republicans on a number of issues—the border. I can remember that I wrote “Mexifornia”, a book calling for strict border security and deportations of illegal aliens, in 2003, and the neoconservative James Q. Wilson, in Commentary, attacked me. And he said that I was sort of paranoid and that my comparisons—that if we didn’t close our border, we’d end up like Europe—were completely ill-founded.

So, they had different views. That group kind of gained steam in 1997, after the first Gulf War. Bill Kristol and Robert Kagan and Dick Cheney at that time, and Don Rumsfeld, Paul Wolfowitz, John Bolton, Francis Fukuyama—they formed something called the Project for the New American Century. They were going to be proactive, and they were going to, in some cases, topple regimes to nation-build, make countries more like us.

They didn’t do much from ’97 until 9/11. And then they came to the fore and said we have to get rid of the Taliban. Ninety percent of Americans agreed with them. And then we can’t just put a theocracy in place, so we’ll put Mr. [Hamid] Karzai in and hope he has a democracy. And we’ll do the same thing with Saddam Hussein, since he was entertaining terrorists.

He was slaughtering his own people. He had threatened George Bush. There were 21 writs that Congress approved. Congress approved going in there. Neither one of those worked out to our satisfaction, and for all practical purposes, neoconservatism was dead because it was responsible, people felt, for two costly wars.

So, as a reaction, Donald Trump came on the scene, and he said, I’m going to be a Jacksonian, not an isolationist, not a neoconservative nation-builder. I will react, or I will be preemptive if I think there is a threat, but I will not get involved on the ground. I will not have lengthy wars. OK, you can argue over Iran, but we have not gotten on the ground, and we’ve only been kinetic for 38 days.

What he was talking about is getting rid of Qasem Soleimani, the Iranian terrorist general, and [Abu Bakr] al-Baghdadi, the ISIS head. In the first term, he destroyed the ISIS caliphate, killed numerous Russian Wagner Group mercenaries, and he got rid of [Nicolas] Maduro. And he bombed Iran in 2025 for about 20 hours. Okay. That was Jacksonianism.

Now the Iranian war has brought out people who say, “Well, there are all these neoconservatives running Trump’s foreign policy.” But I don’t know any people who are in the MAGA movement who are voicing neoconservative domestic policies. No one’s calling for choice, abortion on demand, like many neoconservatives did.

Nobody wants an open border. Nobody wants people to come in across the border illegally and then not to be deported. That’s not part of the movement of MAGA. So, in foreign policy, nobody’s saying we need to put a division in and take over Tehran. Nobody’s saying that we’ve got to remove the regime and then stay there and build a democracy.

It might be viable, might not, but nobody’s saying it. Nobody is even saying that I am a neoconservative and I’m proud of it. No one is. They call Marco Rubio a neoconservative. He’s not saying he’s a neoconservative. He might have said he agreed with neoconservatives 10 years ago or 15, during the Iraq War, but not now.

Who are the neoconservatives? Well, there are two groups, I think. There are people in National Review magazine, there are people in The Dispatch, an online magazine, there are people in The Wall Street Journal, and they feel that, as neoconservatives, they want free and unfettered trade.

They’re against the tariffs. They don’t really care about deporting illegal aliens. They feel that they will assimilate eventually. They feel we’re too restrictive on immigration, that there is always going to be some illegal immigration. They feel deportations are too excessive, or at least they’re bad optics.

And they feel that, from time to time, we might have to go into various countries and occupy them if necessary and build democracies. And the old neoconservatives, the people who were the most prominent, Francis Fukuyama, Bill Kristol, Robert Kagan—they’re all Democrats. They’re all liberals. So what really is the neoconservative label?

What is that label? It’s basically synonymous with your anger at Israel in general and Jewish people in particular. And so now we say you’re a neoconservative, and that is supposed to be a synonym for a puppet of the Israelis or too pro-Jewish.

I want to remind people that Israel receives about .05 of the federal budget and somewhere between 4% and 7% of annual foreign aid, and that’s going to end in 2027.

So the idea that the Israelis are puppet masters and Donald Trump is their puppet is absolutely absurd.

Let me just finish. There are no self-proclaimed neoconservatives. I don’t know anybody in the MAGA movement who says, “I’m a neoconservative.” I do know a lot of people accuse those who supported trying to get rid of the nuclear program in Iran of being neoconservative, but none of them have said, “I’m a neoconservative, and part of neoconservatism is to go into Iran.”

In fact, instead, the people who said you have to deal with that nuclear threat, as Donald Trump is attempting to do, say there are certain parameters. We’re not going to go in and try to change the regime. That would be good if we did, but that’s not our primary goal. It’s to get rid of their nuclear material.

We’re not going to land on the ground with airborne troops. We’re not going to insert the 1st Infantry Division. We’re not going to try to overthrow the regime. None of that. It’s very different. So neoconservatives means really nothing other than a coded and more polite form of saying, “The Jews did it. The Jews did it.”

Marco Rubio Takes Aim at the Global Elite

 

person 1: So, person 2, let’s get your take on [Secretary of State] Marco Rubio’s speech he gave to the Federalist Society last Friday. I’m looking at a headline from Politico: “We’re not the United Nations: Rubio blasts global elite in speech.”

Rubio decried rules-based order enforced by international lawyers and activist courts in a Friday evening broadside, his first address since the midterm elections. Quote, “We Americans, we’re not passive and inward-looking people. To submit to the sterile vision of radical judges or soulless global bureaucrats would be to betray who we are, to betray ourselves.”

It says here also Rubio didn’t break from [President Donald] Trump in his speech, instead mounting a ferocious defense of the administration’s policies in sweeping language and an easy, friendly delivery. He backed the sinking of the alleged drug-smuggling boats, the capture of Venezuela’s former President [Nicolas] Maduro, the administration’s aggressive campaign against immigrants. He defended Iran.

Let me, I’ll finish with this, saying that Tehran’s military buildup had to be addressed and that the Iranian regime was behind every major problem in the Middle East. He defined person 2y in Iran as they can never have a nuclear weapon.

person 2, your take not only on this, but on some of the conservative, quote-unquote, conservative reaction to Marco Rubio.

person 2: Yeah, I was shocked at … It was a very good speech. As I said to Sami [Winc], he quoted one of my favorite lines in Plutarch, Pompey the Great, who wasn’t necessarily an admirable person, but he says to a Sicilian group resisting him, basically, “Stop quoting the laws to those who bear swords,” meaning, in this case, don’t bring up all these technicalities and this moral facade of legality when we have this huge legion right here. And it’s not “might makes right,” but it’s a lot of people hiding behind regulations and the pretense of law and legality when they’re impotent. That’s the way much of Europe works.

And what he’s saying is that the International Criminal Court, the address was addressed to the Federalist Society, so there was a legal framework in which it was delivered. He was saying to them and to the United Nations and the United Nations Commission on Human Rights, Paris Climate Accord, that you all dress up what you do with this legalese, and we’re supposed to obey you and nod because you have this veneer of legality and morality, but you’re not moral.

In the case of the International Criminal Court, you never say that you’re going to find [Russian President] Vladimir Putin or [Chinese leader] Xi Jinping, or you’re going to find the Pakistanis for the way they treat apostates or the Iranians the way they treat women. You only look at Western people because Western people have created you. You’re a product of Western utopian visions.

That’s what happened after World War II. The Third World didn’t create you. They didn’t want to, but they use you. That’s what he was saying. And we’re not going to listen to you anymore.

If you’re in the World Health Organization, and basically, you know that the Chinese lab, Wuhan, created the virus and you’re going to stonewall that because China, you’re terrified of it, and you know that they can do things to you that we won’t even consider doing to you, even though we give you more money than you, we’re supposed to listen to that? We’re supposed to say, “Oh, the United Nations Commission on Human Rights is going to investigate United States racism after George Floyd’s death.” No, we’re not going to listen anymore.

So, that was his speech, and the one thing that struck me is it was an anti-globalist, anti-internationalist speech. It was saying we’re going to make, basically if I could reduce it, I’m not saying he said this explicitly, but the theme was the United States will protect its interest and the interest of its allies. And the subtext of that is because they’re consensual societies. And that’s a clear difference from the alternative.

And he said, “We’re not going to look to slay dragons abroad, but we’re surely not going to ignore people who try to undermine us or attack us.” It was a Jacksonian speech.

But what I got, the essayist Roger Kimball wrote an essay, a note, I guess, on X, and I was looking at the comments. And he said this was very good because it reflected basically the MAGA idea that you don’t trust international bodies, as the Left does, over the primacy of the Constitution. I thought that the MAGA people would love that. I thought that the paleo right would like it. I thought the Groypers would agree. But instead, it was just a litany against Roger Kimball’s essay. You’re a Zionist. You’re a Zionist. You’re a Zionist. You’re a neocon. You’re a neocon. You’re just an intervention. It wasn’t at all. It was disjointed.

It was so angry, but he wasn’t… Rubio, I guess they believe that because years ago he was a neocon, or at least he said he… But there’s nothing in his tenure as the secretary of state that would suggest that.

He had just said the other day he preferred not to use kinetic force to solve the Iranian impasse. He said that everything was going in our way. We had the sanctions tightened, and you may or may not want to tweak some of the land-over routes to the border nations that are supplying Iran. But he wasn’t calling for the destruction of the country or another huge bombing. He’s been at odds sometimes with Pete Hegseth, who have different views on how to resolve it quickly before the midterms.

So I don’t know why the anger is. I know that when we were at National Review, and I think you remember this very well, in 2003, when the Senate and the House voted, I think, to authorize the use of military force against Afghanistan and Iraq. Although the U.N., we didn’t, we did not go to the U.N. about Iraq, there was a cover story by David Frum. You remember that? It was called unpatriot … Was it disloyal or unpatriotic Americans?

person 1: “Unpatriotic Conservatives” seems to …

person 2: Yeah. And that was aimed at the Pat Buchanan wing, right?

person 1: It was.

person 2: Yeah. And I thought that was very unfair because, although I didn’t agree a lot with Pat Buchanan, especially over his anger, there was nothing wrong with opposing the use of force to get rid of Saddam Hussein.

By the way, when the statue fell in Iraq, 90% of the people approved of it. Thirty percent ended up approving it, you know, seven years later or six years later. So people approve or disapprove of a war often on the perception whether it’s going to be brief, decisive, and person 2ious. And when it’s long and it may be losing and it’s costly, they don’t … They suddenly turn on it.

But the point I’m making is that a lot of people thought that David Frum had overreached. I did. That Pat Buchanan was a loyal and patriotic American. He had a difference in opinion on the best way to react to 9/11, and I can’t remember at what he had spelled out, if he thought there was a terrorist threat or we should let Osama bin Laden go ahead and stay in Afghanistan, or we shouldn’t … Saddam Hussein had nothing to do with terrorism. I don’t know what his view was, but it wasn’t unpatriotic.

So, nobody right now …

person 1: Bob Novak also.

person 2: Yeah. Robert Noak. I met Robert Novak once. He was one of the … I thought he was … You know, he had been on that “McLaughlin Group”, and he was considered the Prince of Darkness, remember?

person 1: Right.

person 2: ‘Cause of his short… But actually, he was a Christian convert, he told me, and he had just been diagnosed with a brain tumor, and I saw him at something in Washington. He was one of the most affable people I’d ever met. He was very kind and …

person 1: I’m very fond of him. Yeah. Good guy.

person 2: Yeah. He was a really good guy.

But my point is that if the Republican Party, and we’re going to talk about that in a second. As we keep saying, it wasn’t just the war, it wasn’t just the economy, it wasn’t just corruption. It was the inability of the administration to say that 80% of what the MAGA people wanted, they got. They got the border, they got deportation, they got a reduction in crime. They’ve got the economic indicators are good, although the price of gas was high. They disagreed on the war, and they thought that the 22% increase in prices under Joe Biden should have gone down rather than the rate of inflation and increases in wage making up for that.

But the point is that when this … they got 80% or 90%, they stayed home because they were angry. When you stay home and you’re angry, you get …

And I’ve been watching some of the reactions on the podcast. A lot of people are delighted that the MAGA people have suffered. And I don’t know, Jack, whether they like James Talarico or they like Abdul El-Sayed. Tucker Carlson surely does.

But I don’t know if all of the Groyper right or the Tucker right or the people, the 10% to 20% of Democrat, Republicans that did not turn out in sufficient numbers, but had they done so, it would have been like a 2022 midterm. The in-party would have suffered nine seats and maybe a loss of, and maybe even in the Senate or pick up a seat.

But when you sit out because you don’t get the 10% or 15% you wanted, then you’re essentially voting for what you got, and we’re going to see what we’re going to get, and it’s not going to be affordability, believe me.

Even if they had an agenda, and they don’t, we would have had not 21% inflation. We had something called the Inflation Reduction Act that Biden passed and rammed through. That gave us $7 trillion in spending, and we had 21% to 22% and an immediate 9.1% hike the next year. Had they got Build Back Better, which was even more … it was even more expansive, we would have had 30% inflation.

And so, you wait. We’re going to have an effort to spend like you’ve never seen, and we’re gonna…

person 1: Oh, sure.

person 2: … And they’re going to have to get somebody else’s money from somewhere. And if you think 37% or 38% tax rate is high, wait till they propose 40% or 42% or 44%, and wait till these new blue states start to emulate California.